A Reckless shot at the Central Bank of South Africa by the Public Protector Spells Economic Disaster for the Country Amidst a Recession and Ratings Down Grades: More Kicks for the Economy and South Africa in Turmoil

Anis Mahomed Karodia, Paresh Soni, Alexandru Mircea Nedelea

Abstract


This paper delves into the perplexing issue as captured in the title of the paper. The announcement by the Public Protector will further dampen the economy of South Africa. It will lead to further economic downgrades by the ratings agencies in an era of recession, very high employment, and rising inflation. The issue straddles the reckless shot at the Central Bank by the Public Protector, pushing for change in the Bank’s role, which saw the rand fall by two percent and has deteriorated even further to trade at R13.50 to the US dollar. She has called for a revision of the Reserve Bank’s constitutional mandate. The Public Protector charged that protecting the value of the rand, to a focus on the protection of ‘citizens’ socio – economic wellbeing is cardinal to South Africa’s development. The question arises – Is she doing this at the bidding of the ruling ANC and, supporting the misguided notion of radical economic transformation of the economy, propounded by the President of the country and the African National Congress, given the failure of the ruling ANC government to bring about coordinated development after 23 years of South African democracy. The paper will therefore look at this issue and, elaborate on the possible devastating effects upon an already compromised economy and the, effects upon the general population.  In adding to the narrative, the policy documents of the ANC were critiqued very briefly, in order to show the paranoia that exists within the ruling ANC government, which is aimed at hanging on to power at all costs and, not serving the people of the Republic of South Africa.


Keywords


Central Bank; Economy; Public Protector; Ratings Downgrades; Policies

References


Alan Hirsch (2017). What’s behind Busisiwe’s smoke screen? The Mercury. 22 June. Page 9. Durban. Republic of South Africa.

African National Congress (2017). Policy Documents Released for its July Conference. Released by the African National Congress from Luthuli House. The Headquarters of the ANC. June. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Ann Bernstein (2017). Erasing know – how and creating fictional enemies will not save SA. Business Day. 27 June, Page 7. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Business Day Editorial (2017). More kicks to a fallen economy. 22 June. Page 6. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Business Day Editorial (2017). Reckless shot at central bank. Business Day. 20 June. Page 6. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Business Day Editorial (2017). The business of transformation. June 29. Page 6. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Business Day Editorial (2017. Protector’s inflated role. Business Day. 27 June. Page 6. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Carol Paton (2017). Gigaba set to side with Reserve Bank. Business Day, July 3. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Carol Paton and Sunita Menon (2017). Mkhwebane supports Malikane over Bank. Business day. 21 June. Page 2. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Chris Barron (2017). Protector’s move on mandate is unlawful, dangerous and suspect. Sunday Times. Business Times. 25 June. Page 8. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Christi van der Westhuizen (2017). ANC’s sense of destiny denies will of South African people. The Mercury. 30 June. Page 9. Durban. Republic of South Africa.

Dineo Faku (2017). AngloGold plans to cut 8 500 jobs. Business Report. 29 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Foreign Staff (2017), IMF warning: economy badly exposed to shocks. Business Day. 7 July. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Hilary Joffe (2017). Protector’s agenda a treat to the poor. Business Day. 21 June, Page 6. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Hilary Joffe (2017). Politics the cause of – and solution to – SA’s new economic meltdown. Business Day. Page 7. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Jon Quirk (2017). A rapidly declining South Africa. Business day. 3 July. Page 6. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Keeton, G. (2017). No quick fix getting growth back on track. Business Day. 19 June. Page 7. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Khumal0, K. (2017). 48 000 jobs lost so far this year. Business Report. 28 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Khumalo, K. (2017). Public Protector speech ‘bizarre.’ Business Report. 21 June. Page 17. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Maake, M. and Sunita Menon, (2017). Governor rebuffs public protector report in court. Business Day. 28 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Maake, M. (2017). Mkhwebane’s Bankorp report ‘irrational.’ Business Day. 22 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Mark Allix (2017). Zuma’s mallet has smashed an economy. Business Day. 21 June. Page 10. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Mark Deen (2017). Protectionism threat to investment. Business Report. 08 June. Page 1. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Mbanjwa, B. and ANA (2017). Protector slams illegal bank loan. The Mercury. 20 June. Page 2. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Mbanjwa, B; Hans, B; Koko, K; and Mkhwanazi, S. (2017). Report allegedly ‘targets’ Zuma. The Mercury. 4 July. Page 1. Durban. Republic of South Africa.

Mittner, M. (2017). Rand slides on Mkhwebane’s call for constitutional change. Business Day. 20 June. Page 1. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Natasha Marrian (2017). Ramaphosa: Do not wipe out economy. Business Day. 19 June. Page 3. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Njobeni, S. (2017). Current account deficit reaches 2.1 percent of GDP. Business Report. 21 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Njobeni, S. (2017). Decline in confidence a setback – Moody’s. Business Report. Business Report. 20 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Njobeni, S. (2017). Public Protector spooks the rand. Business Report. 20 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Njobeni, S. (2017). SA in recession. Business Report. 07 June. Page 1. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Njobeni, S. (2017). SA remains lost in economic revolution. Business Report. 28 June. Page 16. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg, Republic of South Africa.

Public Protector (2017). Socioeconomic Model for the Central Bank. SABC Television Services. Prime Time News. 20 June. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Raymond van Nierkerk (2017). The ANC is on the ropes. The Mercury. 29 June. Page 9. Read as Background Reading. Durban. Republic of South Africa.

Roy Cokayne (2017). Downgrades will dampen SA economy. Business Report. 19 June. Page 15. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

SABC Television Services (2017). Public Protector’s Comment. Prime Time News. 20 June. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Seccombe, A. (2017). AngloGold may axe third of workforce. Business Day. June 29. Pages 1 – 2. Read as Background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Ziady, H. (2017). Growth will ‘boost transformation.’ Business Day. 23 June. Page 2. Read as background Reading. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.

Ziady, H. (2017). Protector pushes for change in Bank’s role. Business Day. 20 June. Page 1. Johannesburg. Republic of South Africa.


Full Text: PDF

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.